Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Guide · St Catharines
Discover the top ice cream shops and dessert cafes in St. Catharines. Perfect summer treats and gelato spots.
St. Catharines has moved beyond the soft-serve stands. Over the past few years, the city has quietly assembled a dessert scene worth taking seriously: gelato shops where the fruit actually tastes like fruit, dedicated dessert cafes that treat sweets as the main event rather than an afterthought, and restaurants clever enough to pair a perfect frozen finish with their savory offerings. These aren't chain outposts or novelty stops. They're places locals return to because the quality is there.
The best ice cream in St. Catharines isn't hiding. It's in the gelato counter at Pique-Nique, in the full dessert menu at D Spot, in the genius pairing of pizza and ice cream under one roof at Crust N Cream. It's the casual win of grabbing shawarma and ice cream for pocket change at Shelby's. It's summer done right, and it's accessible without feeling like a special occasion splurge.
This guide rounds up the spots that matter when you're serious about frozen treats in this city. Whether you want refined gelato, a full dessert experience, or ice cream as the perfect ending to something else, here's where to go.
This is where to go if you want gelato that tastes like actual fruit and cream, not a sugar bomb. Their Poached Pear is a standout, with real pear flavour and a silky texture that feels more grown-up than typical ice cream. Perfect for a warm afternoon walk.
A dedicated dessert cafe means the whole menu is built around satisfying your sweet tooth. This is a destination for people who take their treats seriously, not a side thought at a restaurant.
The genius move here is pairing fresh pizza with quality ice cream in one spot. Their Double Deal (Doublicious) is a community favourite. Grab a slice, then finish with a cone without leaving the same place.
Ice cream as an unexpected finishing touch to a shawarma meal might sound odd, but Shelby's does it right. It's the kind of casual spot where you can grab dinner and a frozen treat for under five dollars, making it perfect for budget-conscious summer outings.
Think of this as the brunch-to-dessert destination. Beyond their crepes and pancakes, this spot has smoothies and a thoughtful beverage program that includes creative options like their Lemon Lavender Fizz. The vibe is relaxed and summer-ready.
A Mediterranean cafe that pairs fresh, bright food with coffee and refreshing beverages. In summer, this is your spot for a light meal and a coffee drink that actually tastes good, in a cafe atmosphere that feels European without the airfare.
A bakery component means fresh pastries and baked goods alongside other offerings. Summer dessert lovers appreciate fresh-baked items as much as ice cream, and Johan delivers both.
A dedicated coffee bar means serious attention to beverages and the small bites that go with them. On a hot summer day, a great iced coffee or cold brew from a place that knows what they're doing beats chain coffee shops every time.
Pique-Nique is your answer. This is a proper gelato shop where the texture and flavour matter, not a soft-serve operation pretending to be gelato. Their Poached Pear is the standout, tasting like actual pears with a silky mouthfeel that feels grown-up and intentional. If you care about the difference between gelato and ice cream, this is the place.
Crust N Cream Pizza and Icecream works perfectly for families because kids get pizza (a win) and ice cream (another win) without a second stop. The Double Deal is their signature combo and a community favourite. It's casual, affordable, and satisfying for everyone at the table. For something slightly more upscale, D Spot Dessert Cafe is entirely built around desserts, so no one feels like ice cream is an afterthought.
Yes. D Spot Dessert Cafe is a dedicated dessert destination where everything on the menu centers on satisfying your sweet tooth, not just scoops in a cone. Beyond that, Pür and Simple layers dessert into a broader brunch and beverage program, Johan Restaurant and Bakery pairs fresh baked goods with other offerings, and Lokanta Café Mediterranean Niagara treats dessert and refreshing drinks as part of a full cafe experience. If you want more than just ice cream, these spots deliver.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.