Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · Chatham
Discover Chatham's top pizza spots, from traditional Italian to wood-fired kitchens. Local favourites and hidden gems.
Chatham's pizza scene has evolved beyond delivery chains and frozen crusts. The city is home to a collection of pizzerias and Italian restaurants where the owners actually care about their dough, their sauce, and where their ingredients come from. Wood-fired ovens sit alongside traditional kitchens. Panzerotti specialists compete with upscale dining spots that treat pizza as seriously as their steaks. This isn't accidental: Chatham has built a genuine food culture where pizza means something.
What separates these places isn't just ingredients, though that matters. It's intention. Mamma Maria's brings authentic Italian hospitality and house-made pasta to every table. Centro's open kitchen makes you watch your pizza emerge from proper heat and craftsmanship. Steve's focuses on doing fundamentals right, day after day. Crow City approaches pizza with artisanal creativity. Match pairs their pies with legitimate beer and ribs. Each restaurant earned its reputation by respecting what pizza demands: quality, consistency, and a reason for you to choose them over everywhere else.
Whether you're looking for wood-fired character, casual neighbourhood comfort, or an entire evening built around one meal, Chatham has options that go beyond basic. Here's where to find the pizza that matters in this city.
The clear standout for pizza lovers in Chatham. Mamma Maria's combines authentic Italian hospitality with house-made pasta and properly executed pizzas.
If you're after that authentic wood-fired character, Centro delivers. The open kitchen and live-fire cooking create theatre alongside substance. This is where Chatham's more adventurous eaters go when they want to watch their pizza emerge from proper heat and craftsmanship.
A community favourite for good reason. Steve's Panzerotti ranks as the top-ranked panzerotti dish in Chatham, and their Chicken Fingers are equally celebrated.
A more upscale approach to dining in Chatham. Forte offers sushi, steak, burgers, and pasta alongside pizza, creating a destination where you can build an entire evening. The Pear and Blue salad ranks among Chatham's top dishes. Around $24 per meal, this is where you go for occasion dining.
Classic Chatham institution vibes. Andy's isn't trying to reinvent pizza, it's perfecting the craft of neighbourhood comfort food.
If you want your pizza paired with serious beer and ribs, Match is the destination. Their Guinness ranks among Chatham's top beers, and the I Want My Baby Back Ribs are legendary.
For those who want pizza with creative edge, Crow City brings artisanal sensibility. The Focaccia Salami and Tomato Jam sandwich shows their commitment to quality, layered flavours, and non-traditional approaches. Perfect for lunch or a lighter meal where ingredients matter more than portion size.
The name is honest. Shawarma and More means pizza sits alongside Middle Eastern expertise. The top-ranked shawarma in its category tells you the kitchen knows how to execute. It's a casual spot where pizza is part of a diverse menu, great if you're dining with people who want different things.
Specialization breeds excellence. Chris' Sausage focuses on what it does best, and ranks in the top 3 of its category for good reason. If you want pizza with properly made sausage toppings, this is the place. Casual, straightforward, and deeply committed to ingredient quality.
Quick, reliable, and casual. Fuel 4 You+ serves pizza as part of a grab-and-go menu for Chatham's busier crowd. Not fancy, but consistent. Good for when you want to fuel up without ceremony.
Mamma Maria's Ristorante stands at the top. It combines authentic Italian hospitality with house-made pasta and properly executed pizzas in a wood-fired setting. This is a full dining experience where regulars feel at home and the community has clearly spoken. Expect to spend around $22 per meal for the kind of pizza that rewards your attention.
Centro Wood Fired Kitchen is your destination for authentic wood-fired character. The open kitchen and live-fire cooking create both theatre and substance. This is where Chatham's more adventurous eaters go when they want to watch their pizza emerge from proper heat and craftsmanship. Mamma Maria's also features wood-fired tradition alongside their full Italian menu.
Steve's Pizzeria delivers community-favourite pizza with panzerotti and wings that rank among Chatham's best. Andy's Place offers classic neighbourhood comfort food vibes where consistency comes from decades of repetition. For grab-and-go options, Fuel 4 You+ serves reliable pizza as part of their casual menu. All three respect the fundamentals without pretension.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants, city by city.