Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · Pelham
Discover top-rated pizzerias in Pelham. From classic slices to gourmet pies, find your next pizza night.
Pelham's pizza scene has quietly become something worth talking about. This isn't a town where the big chains define what's on the table. Instead, you've got pizzerias where the dough fermentation actually matters, where wood-fired ovens aren't a gimmick, and where the person tossing the pie genuinely cares about what lands on your plate.
Walk into any of these spots and you'll notice the difference immediately. At Volcanos, the cheezy bread alone has become legendary enough that locals cite it as proof of craft. At Italian Peasant Gastro Market, their Calabrese pizza tastes like someone understood the assignment. Even the casual spots here, like Rockway Summer Shack, refuse to cut corners just because the price is right. Pelham has built a pizza culture that respects the fundamentals while staying unpretentious.
Whether you want to sit down with a cocktail and share plates, grab a slice on your way somewhere, or treat pizza as the centerpiece of an evening out, Pelham has options that actually deliver.
Their cheezy bread is legendary enough to be ranked highest in its category, which tells you everything about the care they put into every item. This is where you go when you want pizza that tastes like someone actually cares about the dough, sauce, and cheese pairing.
A pizzeria confident enough to showcase chocolate fudge cake alongside their pies, Pie Guys understands that a great pizza spot feeds more than just hunger. Their pizza game is complemented by desserts that suggest serious kitchen skills and creativity beyond the basics.
This is where tradition meets quality. Their Calabrese pizza ranks as a community favourite, and their pasta tomato sauce is equally celebrated.
Sometimes you want familiarity and reliability, and Pizza Pizza delivers that in Pelham. Perfect for quick slices or when you're feeding a crowd and want consistent quality without fuss.
While tapas-focused, Cured ranks at the top of its category and represents the kind of elevated casual dining scene Pelham has developed. If you're open to pizza as part of a larger grazing experience with cocktails, this spot delivers an experience rather than just a meal.
A casual, affordable spot (averaging around $6 per meal) that doesn't cut corners on quality. Summer Shack brings that laid-back vibe where pizza tastes better under an open sky, and the price point means you can try multiple slices without guilt.
Not strictly pizza, but their community-ranked steam chicken dumplings and satay chicken show a kitchen that respects technique and flavor. If you're exploring Pelham's broader food scene while hunting for pizza, Young's is worth a detour for contrast and quality.
A more upscale option (around $40 per meal) that brings sophistication to the dining experience. If you're celebrating or want pizza as part of a full restaurant experience with wine pairings and careful plating, this is where Pelham's pizza culture gets dressed up.
Volcanos Pizzeria is the place that takes dough, sauce, and cheese seriously enough to make it shorthand for a good pizza night in town. Italian Peasant Gastro Market brings that same commitment to tradition and proper sourcing, with their Calabrese pizza standing as a community favorite. Both spots treat the fundamentals like they matter, which is exactly what separates real wood-fired craft from the rest.
Rockway Summer Shack delivers quality without the guilt. You're looking at around $6 per meal, which makes it easy to try multiple slices and actually taste what the kitchen can do. Pizza Pizza in Pelham is your reliable option when you need to feed a crowd quickly and want consistent quality without fuss. Both spots get you fed without pretense.
Pie Guys Pizzeria proves a pizza shop can offer serious kitchen range by serving chocolate fudge cake alongside their pies. Cured Tapas and Cocktails sits at the top of its category and lets you treat pizza as part of a larger grazing experience with cocktails and elevated casual dining. If you want to go full celebration mode, Domenic's On 20 brings sophistication and wine pairings to the pizza experience, running around $40 per meal for the full restaurant treatment.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.