Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · Renfrew
Discover where to eat the best pizza in Renfrew. From classic chains to local gems, find your perfect slice.
Renfrew's pizza scene doesn't fit a single mold. You've got bare-bones drive-ins slinging $5 pies next to ambitious kitchens where pizza shares menu space with Korean influences and seafood preparations. It's the kind of town where your pizza choice says something about what kind of meal you're after, not just what you're hungry for.
The real story here is diversity masquerading as a small-town food scene. Whether you want to grab a slice between errands, settle in for a proper dinner, or catch a game with a crowd, there's a specific place in Renfrew built for exactly that. Some joints treat pizza as an institution. Others treat it as one instrument in a bigger culinary toolkit.
This isn't about ranking pizza joints by some invisible metric. It's about matching your craving, your budget, and your vibe to the right spot. The town's got options. You just need to know where to point yourself.
A true local institution where pizza is served alongside burgers and wings in a casual drive-in atmosphere. At around $5 per meal, this is where you go for honest, no-nonsense pizza without pretense. The kind of place that's been feeding Renfrew for years.
If you're craving consistent, familiar pizza with options like Hawaiian and pepperoni, Domino's delivers (literally). At roughly $20 a meal, it's reliable and caters to both traditional preferences and those wanting to experiment with toppings.
A dedicated pizzaria that keeps things simple and affordable at around $5 per meal. This is comfort food done right, the kind of neighborhood spot where regulars know what they're getting and come back for exactly that reason.
A Greek-influenced spot that doesn't limit itself to one thing. Their pizza sits alongside hot sandwiches, pasta, and poutine, giving you the freedom to build a meal however you want. The kind of place that works for any craving.
A classic diner serving breakfast, burgers, and pizza in a genuine neighborhood setting. Pizza here is part of the equation, not the whole story, making it perfect if your crew has split opinions on what to eat.
Pizza meets sports bar culture. At around $9 per meal, this is where you grab a slice, catch the game, and soak in the energy. The vibe here is just as important as the food.
A bistro that treats pizza with care, offering it alongside thoughtful appetizers, cheese platters, and vegetarian options. At around $15 per meal, there's a sense that someone's thinking about quality here, not just volume.
An ambitious kitchen that spans multiple cuisines with pizza as one option among many (Korean, seafood, Italian influences all coexist). If you want pizza but also want to feel like you're eating somewhere with real culinary range, this is it.
The familiar chain presence in Renfrew, where pizza comes with pastas and appetizers in a family-friendly setting. Reliable when you know what to expect.
Known for breakfast but they swing towards lunch and dinner with pizza on the menu. At around $16 per meal, it's a spot where you could pop in for a leisurely meal that's not rushed.
Odi's Kingburger Drive-In and Slice of Renfrew Pizzaria both land around $5 per meal, making them the most budget-friendly options in town. Odi's runs the classic drive-in playbook with burgers and wings alongside pizza, while Slice of Renfrew keeps things stripped down and comfortable. If you're willing to go slightly higher, Final Score Sports Bar hits around $9 and doubles as a place to catch the game.
Manitou Bistro and Finnigan's Roadhouse Renfrew are the spots where pizza gets deliberate attention. Manitou pairs it with thoughtful appetizers and cheese platters, signaling that someone's thinking about quality and balance. Finnigan's treats pizza as one part of a wider culinary range, sitting alongside Korean dishes and seafood. If you want pizza that feels intentional rather than obligatory, these two deliver.
Final Score Sports Bar is built for this. At around $9 per meal, it's where pizza meets live games and crowd energy. If you want something slightly more relaxed but still social, Step'N Back Diner gives you that genuine neighborhood diner feel where pizza is one of several reasons to stick around. Karras' Way also works if your group has split opinions, since you can build meals however you want across pizza, hot sandwiches, pasta, and poutine.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.