Regional Roundup · Simcoe
Discover the top pizza spots in Simcoe. From classic pizzerias to creative pies, find your next favourite slice.
Simcoe's pizza scene doesn't need chains to thrive. While the familiar names exist for late-night convenience, locals know where the real action happens—at Twin City Pizza, where decades of perfected fundamentals mean a crust worth the visit, and at neighbourhood spots like Fat Back BBQ where smoked meat meets dough with serious intent. The city's best pizza isn't hiding. It's sitting in casual kitchens, patios, and coffee shops, made by people who treat it as more than a delivery item.
Whether you're after straightforward reliability, creative indulgence, or a pizza experience wrapped in good atmosphere, Simcoe has stripped away the pretension. These aren't destinations you'd travel for—they're the places you actually go when you live here and know better.
A Simcoe institution that does the fundamentals right. Twin City Pizza nails the balance between crispy crust and generous toppings—the kind of straightforward, reliable pizza that keeps people coming back for decades.
A casual spot that treats pizza as part of a bigger food story. At around $10 for a meal, it's accessible without cutting corners on quality, and the neighbourhood vibe makes it perfect for a quick, unpretentious lunch.
For late-night cravings and consistent delivery, Domino's in Simcoe fills the gap when you want pizza without the wait. Reliable comfort food that works when convenience matters.
A spot that blends coffee culture with casual eating. While known for their brews, they bring creativity to their food offerings—including pizza that feels considered and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for lingering.
If you're craving meat-loaded pizza with serious flavour, Fat Back brings their BBQ expertise to creative pies. Smoky, hearty, and unapologetically indulgent—perfect for those who want their pizza to be a meal.
A destination with outdoor patio appeal where the menu spans beyond tacos. Summer pizza on the patio with great atmosphere makes this worth the visit when weather cooperates.
A homestyle kitchen that brings personality to every plate. Their pizza reflects care and local ingredients—the kind of place where you taste the thought that went into what you're eating.
While known for shawarma, DT Shawarma's expanded menu includes quality pizza options. It's the kind of casual spot where you can grab a solid slice without pretension, in an unpretentious neighbourhood setting.
A cafe with cafe charm that doesn't skip on their kitchen offerings. Cozy and intimate, it's ideal for a slower pizza experience paired with good conversation and coffee.
Coffee-forward but food-serious. Their pizza pairs well with what they do best—quality espresso—making it a go-to for those who want their slice with a great cup.
Domino's in Simcoe handles late-night delivery with consistent results when speed and convenience matter most. But if you can pick up instead, Twin City Pizza delivers the kind of quality that justifies the trip—their crust and topping balance beats anything arriving in a box. DT Shawarma also offers solid pizza options for casual neighbourhood delivery without pretension.
Fat Back BBQ brings genuine creativity by treating pizza as an extension of their BBQ program—smoky, meat-forward, and unapologetically indulgent. For atmosphere, Lily's Tacos' outdoor patio transforms pizza into a summer experience, while The Creative Bru-tique and Belching Barista elevate the meal by pairing pizza with genuinely good coffee. Lola Letty's Kitchen stands out for homestyle care that reflects local ingredients and thought in every plate.
Neighbourhood Food Emporium hits the sweet spot at around $10 for a meal without cutting corners on quality—casual, unpretentious, and accessible. DT Shawarma and Kingfisher Cafe also deliver solid pizza at neighbourhood prices, the kind of places where you grab a slice without overthinking it. Twin City Pizza's straightforward approach means you're paying for quality fundamentals, not markup.
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.