Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · St Catharines
Discover the top pizza spots in St. Catharines, Ontario. From classic Italian to creative fusion, find your next favorite slice.
St. Catharines doesn't have the pizza reputation of Toronto or Niagara-on-the-Lake, which is exactly why its pizza scene is worth your attention. The restaurants here aren't chasing trends or competing on hype. They're making pizza because they actually know how to cook.
You'll find wood-fired traditionalists sitting next to fusion experimenters, Mediterranean cafes serving alongside Middle Eastern grills, and neighbourhood spots where pizza is the main event rather than an afterthought. What ties them together is craft. The kitchens respect their ingredients, they understand flavour building, and they're not cutting corners on quality.
This is a guide to where that care shows up on your plate, organized by what you're actually looking for when you're hungry in St. Catharines.
This spot does exactly what the name promises, blending classic pizza fundamentals with unexpected toppings and flavour combinations that keep regulars coming back. If you're tired of plain cheese and pepperoni, Pizza Fusion proves St. Catharines has room for creative ambition.
A neighbourhood favourite that treats pizza as just one part of a larger breakfast and lunch story. Their pizza shows up alongside crepes and eggs benedict, suggesting a kitchen that respects quality across the menu. The casual, welcoming vibe makes it perfect for a quick lunch or lazy weekend meal.
A proper Italian restaurant that takes its craft seriously. Their Polo Parmigiana is community-ranked as a standout, signalling a kitchen that understands Italian cooking from the ground up.
Mediterranean cooking shows up in many cuisines, and Lokanta proves that pizza can benefit from that broader worldview. With options for dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan diets, this spot welcomes everyone. The casual café vibe and reasonable prices make it accessible for any pizza mood.
A top-ranked community favourite that brings Middle Eastern and grilled flavours to the table. While known for kebabs and grilled meats, the kitchen clearly understands flavour building and quality ingredients, which translates to any pizza they put out. This is where neighbourhoods gather.
The name says it all. This is a restaurant built on pizza, full stop. Community members rank their deep fried wonton as a standout appetizer, suggesting a kitchen that sweats the details on both sides of the menu. If you want a place where pizza is the main event, this is it.
A casual spot that treats quesadillas, salads, sandwiches, and pizza with equal respect. The fact that they rank well across multiple categories suggests versatility and consistency. Good for when your group can't agree on what to eat, but everyone wants something fresh and well-made.
An American-style grill that likely brings bold, hearty flavours to their pizza game. The name suggests a place with personality and confidence in their cooking approach. Good for when you want pizza with a different regional twist and maybe a cold drink to wash it down.
The St. Catharines pizza scene leans toward modern ovens and traditional kitchen approaches rather than the wood-fired aesthetic you might find elsewhere. Coppola's Ristorante brings authentic Italian technique and takes pizza seriously as part of a full Italian dining experience. If you're specifically hunting for that smoky, high-heat character, Bourbon St. Grill's American-style approach and Pizza House's focus on pizza as the main event suggest kitchens that understand bold, direct cooking methods. Your best bet is to call ahead and ask about their oven setup before making the trip.
Lokanta Café - Mediterranean Niagara explicitly offers dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan pizza options, making it the go-to spot if you have dietary restrictions. They've built their menu around accessibility without compromising on flavour. For other restaurants on this list, a quick phone call will tell you what they can accommodate, since many kitchens are willing to adapt their pizza but don't always advertise it.
Pizza House and Pizza Fusion are both built around pizza as the central offering, making them reliable choices for delivery that arrive ready to eat. Pür & Simple works as a quick lunch spot with reasonable prices and consistent quality. The trade-off with delivery is that pizza loses heat and texture by the time it arrives, so places that excel at takeout speed and consistent execution matter more than oven theatrics. Call and ask about delivery times before ordering, especially during peak hours.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.