Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · Stayner
Discover Stayner's best pizza spots. From classic wood-fired to creative specialty pies, find your new favorite pizzeria.
Stayner's pizza scene doesn't apologize for its size. What it lacks in restaurant count, it makes up for in places that treat pizza like something worth getting right. The difference between a pizza joint and a craft pizzeria shows up in the dough, the sourcing, and whether the person making your pie actually tastes it before it leaves the kitchen. In Stayner, that difference is real and worth seeking out.
The town has cultivated a collection of spots where pizza lives alongside other strengths: wings that build reputations, ramen that demands technique, fish that requires proper sourcing. This isn't a town that settled for one-note restaurants. Instead, Stayner's pizza places exist within kitchens that care about the full picture, which means your pizza tastes like it came from somewhere with standards.
Whether you're hunting for gluten-free crust, a taco pizza hybrid, or just a solid slice at lunch prices, Stayner delivers without pretense. This is neighborhood food made by people who know their regulars by name and treat newcomers the same way.
The clear community favorite for pizza in Stayner, Creemore brings a craft approach to every pie. Their gluten-free crust option means nobody gets left out, and the Greek salad (topped-ranked dish here) suggests a kitchen that respects ingredient quality.
La Benita proves that a neighborhood pizza spot can do more than just pizza. Their taco pizza is a standout (it's the community's top-ranked taco pizza), and the wings are legendary.
Ranked highest in overall community favorites, Street'Oh'Classical delivers a full restaurant experience that happens to include excellent pizza. This is where you go when you want more than just a pie and want to linger over a meal.
While Kitch'n Savvy isn't exclusively a pizzeria, they understand comfort food through and through. At around $9 per meal, it's one of the most affordable stops on this list, and the kitchen delivers top-ranked dishes across multiple categories (shawarma, poutine, Greek).
A reliable, familiar option when you want to know exactly what you're getting. Pizza Hut delivers consistent results and caters well to larger groups or delivery orders. Not a destination spot, but a solid fallback when you want pizza without surprises.
Stepping outside pure pizza territory, Honey Monster shows what happens when a kitchen genuinely cares about technique across multiple cuisines. Their top-ranked ramen, sushi rolls, and chicken sandwich suggest a team that's invested in doing things right.
A social gathering spot with a full menu that includes solid pizza options. The vibe here leans toward community hangout, making it ideal for groups or when you want to turn dinner into an evening. Around $10 per meal keeps it wallet-friendly for casual outings.
If your pizza night might evolve into ordering seafood, Bluewater covers that pivot. Their strength in fish and grill items means they take sourcing seriously, which translates to quality across the menu. A solid choice when your group can't agree on a single cuisine.
Creemore Pizza Co. Stayner is your answer. They take gluten-free seriously enough to offer it as a standard crust option, not an afterthought. This approach reflects their broader philosophy: quality ingredients and technique matter for everyone at the table. Their Greek salad pairs well if you're building a full meal around the gluten-free pizza.
Kitch'n Savvy keeps meals around $9 per person, making it the budget-friendly leader. They don't sacrifice on execution though, with top-ranked dishes across shawarma, poutine, and Greek food. If you want pizza without spending much, this is where you go. 1904 Social Haus hovers around $10 per meal if Kitch'n Savvy isn't in your neighborhood.
Pizza Hut offers reliable delivery service with consistent results if you want a familiar option. For something with more character, check whether Creemore Pizza Co. or La Benita Pizza & Wings deliver to your address. La Benita's neighborhood feel and standout wings make them worth the call if they service your area. Always confirm delivery availability directly, as coverage varies by location.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants, city by city.