Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · Lake Placid
Use this RankIt guide to choose pizza in Lake Placid, from Main Street slices to wood-fired pies, brewpub pizzas, and cash-only neighborhood moves.
Searching for pizza in Lake Placid gets messy fast. The results jump between Reddit threads, broad review directories, and individual restaurant menus, which is not much help when you are hungry after a hike, a rink session, or a long drive into town.
This guide keeps the choice practical: slices, sit-down Italian, newer pizzerias, and brewpub pies that actually make sense for the moment. For the full local board, browse pizza in Lake Placid, then compare it with the overall Lake Placid rankings.
Main Street Pizza is the straightforward downtown move: slices, whole pies, calzones, pasta, and the kind of late-ish hours that matter when dinner plans slip. Its current menu points hard at the classics, with Grandma pizza, cheese, pepperoni, white pies, wings, garlic knots, and baked pasta all in the mix.
Go here if your group wants pizza without a ceremony. It is especially useful for takeout near the center of town, where nobody wants to debate sauce philosophy for twenty minutes.
Mr. Mike's is the old-school Italian dinner version of the Lake Placid pizza run. The restaurant lists traditional and signature pizzas, plus calzones, pasta, salads, and beer and wine, so it works when one person wants a pie and another wants something more fork-and-knife.
This is the move for families, teams, and anyone staying near the Olympic Center. It is close enough to be convenient, but broad enough that pizza does not have to carry the whole table.
Garage Pizza is the smaller, newer branch of the Mr. Mike orbit, built around a casual pizzeria setup on McKinley Street. The official site positions it as hand-crafted pizza with an old-world Italian angle, and it notes cash-only service, which is the kind of detail you want before walking in.
Pick Garage when you want a tighter pizzeria feel instead of the full Italian restaurant experience. It is also a useful call when you want a focused pizza night without wandering the busiest stretch of Main Street.
Ere's Pizza is a Main Street pizzeria with enough range to handle both slice cravings and sit-down comfort food. Its current ordering menu lists large pies, personal pizzas, cheese and pepperoni slices, specialty pies, calzones, wings, sandwiches, and fried starters.
Go here if you want a more built-out pizza menu, especially for toppings-heavy pies. The lakeside/Main Street location also makes it easy to fold into a casual downtown night without turning dinner into a project.
Bazzi's is another classic Main Street option, with New York-style pizza, specialty pies, calzones, hot subs, baked pasta, and wings. The menu footprint is useful for mixed groups: one person can stay on pizza, someone else can go chicken parm, and nobody has to pretend a salad is dinner.
This is a good pick for a casual, filling meal. It is not trying to be precious, which is often exactly what you want from a pizza place in a mountain town.
Caffè Rustica is the more composed Italian dinner choice. Its official site calls out Mediterranean cooking and wood-fired pizzas, with evening service on Saranac Avenue, so it fits the night when pizza is still the plan but you want a real dinner room around it.
Go here if you care less about a quick slice and more about a sit-down meal with wine, pasta, and a better-paced table. It is the sensible upgrade pick when the group wants pizza but not paper plates.
Big Slide is not a slice shop, and that is the point. The brewery's current menu includes brick-oven pizzas made with house dough from Bake Placid, alongside beer, pub snacks, burgers, and larger entrees.
Choose it when pizza is part of a bigger brewery meal. It is the right fit for a table that wants pepperoni or a seasonal pie, but also wants beer flights, snacks, and enough non-pizza options to keep everyone easy.
Lisa G's is the off-Main-Street curveball. Its official menu notes that pizzas and entrees are not available until after 4 PM, and the online menu shows creative pies like hot meats, cheese, pepperoni, and seasonal-style combinations.
This is the move if you want pizza with a more restaurant-bar personality. It is better for dinner than a quick lunch slice, and it gives you a break from the most obvious downtown loop.
Lake Placid Pub & Brewery works when you want a casual pub meal and pizza is one of the strong options. The current menu lists cheese, margherita, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, and vegetable-forward pizzas, plus wings, burgers, and a full beer lineup.
Go here for the post-activity group meal: easy, loud enough, and built for people who want different things. The pizza is useful because it sits inside a bigger pub menu, not because anyone needs another delicate dinner decision.
Main Street Pizza and Ere's Pizza are the easiest quick-slice style picks near the Main Street flow. Check current hours before you go, especially outside peak visitor weekends.
Mr. Mike's Pizza and Italian Kitchen, Caffè Rustica, Lisa G's, Big Slide Brewery, and Lake Placid Pub & Brewery all make more sense when you want to sit down instead of just grab a box.
Mr. Mike's, Lake Placid Pub & Brewery, Big Slide, Bazzi's, and Main Street Pizza are the safest group calls because their menus stretch beyond plain pies. That matters when one person wants pizza and someone else wants wings, pasta, or a burger.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants, city by city.