Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Editorial Guide · Pelham
Pelham's most underrated spots — from tapas in Fonthill to Korean fusion, wine estates, and a seasonal summer shack. Ranked on RankIt.
Pelham isn't a restaurant city in any obvious sense. The municipality is a loose collection of communities — Fonthill, Fenwick, Ridgeville — spread across the Niagara escarpment and into the wine country corridor near Jordan Station. There's no main street lined with patios, no downtown dining scene. The food worth finding here is scattered across strip plazas, farm roads, and the odd seasonal setup.
These are the spots ranking highest on RankIt for the Pelham area. If you live here, a few will already be familiar. If you're coming through the region, this is a practical guide to what's actually worth stopping for. The full Pelham ranking is the place to dig further.
Near Seventeenth Street in the wine country edge of Pelham, Rockway Summer Shack is a seasonal operation — which is part of the point. Meals average under $7, and it ranks at the top of RankIt's Pelham listings. Seasonal, affordable, and located in one of the more scenic stretches of the Niagara region. Worth timing your visit around before the season closes.
Korean food wasn't what Pelham Street was known for, but Choi's Roll & Bowl has changed that. The name is direct: rice bowls and rolls, which covers a lot of territory in the right hands. It sits near the top of RankIt's Pelham rankings. If your usual default in the area is pizza or fast food, this is the clearest reason to reconsider.
Tapas and cocktails in Fonthill is the kind of thing you wouldn't expect until you've been there. Cured sits in a unit on Pelham Street and is ranked among Pelham's top sit-down options on RankIt. It's the sort of place that works for an evening out when you want something that isn't chain food and doesn't require a highway drive into the city.
On Pelham Street in Fonthill, Gelato Village does one thing and does it well. Artisan gelato, average around $11, consistently ranked near the top for Pelham on RankIt. A natural stop if you're already eating in the Fonthill core — before or after whatever else you've planned.
Finding decent Thai food in a small Ontario town is always a minor surprise. Young's Thai Cuisine on Highway 20 East is a well-established part of the local dining landscape and shows up consistently in RankIt's Pelham rankings. Around $16 average per meal — reasonable for a sit-down dinner. The kind of neighbourhood spot that becomes a regular for people who live close enough to stop by.
Highway 20 East in Fonthill isn't a dining destination, but Domenic's On 20 makes it one. This is the closest thing Pelham has to a proper dinner restaurant — the upper end of local prices at around $40 per person, and ranked to match. If you're marking an occasion or want a full sit-down meal without heading to Niagara-on-the-Lake or St. Catharines, this is the answer.
Out of Victoria Avenue in Fenwick, Country Boys is a mobile operation — which means you need to know when and where they're set up. Meals average around $8. Mobile food in rural Niagara has a specific rhythm to it, and Country Boys has built a following in Pelham's southern communities. When they're out, they're worth finding.
On Seventeenth Street in the escarpment edge of Pelham, Westcott is a Niagara estate winery with a food program that brings the average visit to around $37 per person. It's not a restaurant in the standalone sense, but it's one of the more complete experiences in the wine country corridor — estate wines, escarpment views, and enough on the food side to make an afternoon of it.
On Sixteen Road in the escarpment stretch of Pelham, Domaine Queylus leans heavily Burgundian — pinot noir and chardonnay territory. The experience is wine-first, but it's also a setting that earns a visit for its own sake. Ranked among Pelham's top spots on RankIt. If you're building a wine country day through this part of Niagara, Queylus and Westcott together make a natural pairing along the escarpment.
Scattered but worthwhile. Fonthill has the most dining concentration in the municipality — Cured, Gelato Village, Young's Thai, and Domenic's On 20 are all within a short radius of each other. The wine country edge near Jordan Station adds a different kind of dining experience through Westcott Vineyards and Domaine Queylus. It's not a big-city dining scene, but the best spots in Pelham hold up well against comparable options in larger Niagara communities.
Yes — Gelato Village is an easy call for families, and Young's Thai Cuisine is casual enough for a relaxed dinner with kids. Country Boys Mobile Food Services in Fenwick is a practical option when you want inexpensive food in a more open setting. Rockway Summer Shack, when in season, is another family-appropriate stop worth knowing about.
Cured Tapas & Cocktails is the top-ranked sit-down option in Fonthill on RankIt. Gelato Village is worth adding to any visit. Young's Thai Cuisine is just outside the Fonthill core on Highway 20 East. For a higher-end dinner, Domenic's On 20 is on the same highway. Between those four options, you've covered most of what Fonthill has to offer for an evening out.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.