Best Pizza in St. Catharines

20 places ranked · 1 community vote

Discover the best Pizza in St. Catharines, ranked with early community input and local data. Crust N Cream Pizza & Icecream currently holds the top spot, with Maestro's Pizzeria and Cat's Caboose among the other top picks. A standout dish to try: the Double Deal (Doublicious). Menu prices: $7 – $53. Add your own rankings to help others find great Pizza in St. Catharines.

Filter:

Aggregated from all community votes.

Crust N Cream Pizza & Icecream

Manger Special Party Slab · Wing Pizza Combo · BBQ Bacon Chicken Pizza +22 more pizzas

Maestro's Pizzeria

Medium Pizza & Wings Combo · Large Combo Deal · Medium Combo Deal +9 more pizzas

Cat's Caboose

Bean Bar Pita Pizza · Pizza Antipastos · Score Pizza

Rickijo's

Mediterranean Pizza · Carnivore · Carnivore Meat Lovers Pizza +13 more pizzas

Super 2 For 1 Pizza

Single X-Large Pizza · Single XLarge Pizza · Single XLarge Pizza (Delivery) +19 more pizzas

Chile & Agave Mexican Grill

Quesapizza · Quesapizza Birria · Enchilada Suiza +1 more pizzas

Di’s Pizza Pies

Buffalo Chicken · Diablo · La Rib +9 more pizzas

Rollin' Pizza - Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta

Detroit - Diva · Real Beef MeatBall & Regotta Pizza · Vegan Detroit Margherita +24 more pizzas

Wrigley's Sports Bar & Lounge

Canadian Pizza (Large) · Meat Lovers Pizza (Large) · Pepperoni Pizza (Large) +4 more pizzas

Fabio's Pizza

Pizza Hawaiano · Pizza Margharita · Pizza Siciliano

Fat Cat's Pizza Inc.

No menu data yet

Fat Louie's Pizzeria & Bar

No menu data yet

B22 - Brar 22 pizza St Catharines

X-Large Pizza · X-Large Combo Deals · Large Combo Deals +8 more pizzas

Domino's Pizza

Large Feast Pizza · BBQ Chicken Bacon · Brooklyn +16 more pizzas

1 ranking$9 – $21

Pie Guys Pizzeria

Steak Pizza Pie (12 Slice) · The New Yorker · Steak Pizza Pie (8 Slice) +12 more pizzas

Red Swan Pizza - St. Catharines West

Thin Crust · Traditional Crust · Vegan Pizza

Volcano Pizzeria

The Works · Classic White · Medium Cauliflower +9 more pizzas

Kim's Wooden Nicol

Grilled Cheese with a few Chips

oddBar.

Counterpart Pizza Pils

Pür & Simple

Canadian

Think you know the best Pizza in St. Catharines?

Rank them yourself. Drag your favourites into order and settle it. Free in the app.

Download on theApp Store Get it onGoogle Play

Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there

Nearby Cities

Pizza in Thorold Pizza in Pelham Pizza in Niagara Falls Pizza in Niagara-on-the-Lake Pizza in Ridgeville