🏪 Is this your restaurant? Claim your free listing on RankIt.

Claim this listing →

Fort Erie / Cafe 59

Cafe 59

62 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA

Cafe 59 is a full service restaurant and bar in Fort Erie, offering an eclectic menu that transitions from an upbeat lunch spot to a vibrant dinner venue. With house made ingredients including soups, sauces, focaccia bread, and salad dressings, as well as vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, there's something for everyone. Enjoy daily specials, Sunday brunch, and a full service bar with an extensive beer list and creative cocktails.

Menu

Chicken Finger Wrap

$17.75

Signature Soup

$7.75

Grilled Focaccia, Cucumber Meatballs

🌱V
$4.50

Vegetarian Polenta 'Wings'

🌱V
$14.50

Chicken Finger Classic

$19.75

Grilled Portobello

🌱V
$17.75

Grilled Chicken & Pesto

$18.75

Chicken, Bacon & Fig

$19

59 Parmesan Bomber Chicken

$19.50

59 Parmesan Bomber Meatball

$19.50

59 Parmesan Bomber Fried Eggplant

🌱V
$18.50

Caesar Wrap Chicken

$17.75

Caesar Wrap Polenta

🌱V
$17.75

Caesar Wrap Portobello

🌱V
$17.75

Bourbon Wrap Chicken

$17.75

Bourbon Wrap Polenta

🌱V
$17.75

Bourbon Wrap Falafel

🌿VE🌱V
$17.75

Chicken Finger Wrap Chicken

$17.75

Chicken Finger Wrap Polenta

🌱V
$17.75

Chicken Finger Wrap Falafel

🌿VE🌱V
$17.75

Chopped Asian Wrap Chicken

$17.75

Chopped Asian Wrap Polenta

🌱V
$17.75

Chopped Asian Wrap Portobello

🌱V
$17.75

Teriyaki Stir Fry Polenta

🌱V
$22.50

Teriyaki Stir Fry Portobello

🌱V
$22.50

Bourbon Bowl Polenta

🌱V
$22.50

Bourbon Bowl Falafel

🌿VE🌱V
$22.50

Bourbon Bowl Shrimp

$26.75

Bourbon Bowl Salmon

$26.75

Cajun Alfredo Smoked Sausage

$22.50

59 Parmesan Eggplant

🌱V
$22.50

59 Parmesan Meatball

$23.25

59 Parmesan Chicken

$24.50

Tabbouleh

Side of tabbouleh

🌿VE🌱V
$10.25

Caesar Salad (starter)

Starter Caesar salad

🌱V
$9.25

Fried Artichokes

Caper mayo, Romano, lemon

🌱V
$14.50

House Salad (entrée)

Field greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, celery, carrot, crouton, balsamic vinaigrette

🌱V
$12.75

Mediterranean Salad

Field greens, hummus, tabbouleh, roasted eggplant, cucumber, tomato, chickpeas, feta, Greek dressing, focaccia

🌱V
$19.95

Fried Polenta or Falafel Salad

Salad with fried polenta or falafel

🌱V
$18.50

59 Club

Texas toast, roasted turkey, bacon, field greens, tomato, American cheese, mayo

$18.75

59 Parmesan Bomber - Chicken or Meatball

Sub roll, red sauce, provolone cheese, Romano with chicken or meatball

$19.50

Eggplant & Artichoke Wrap

Roasted eggplant, artichoke hearts, feta, field greens, tomato, lemon-dill dressing

🌱V
$17.25

Bourbon Wrap (Salmon)

Vegetable fried rice, bourbon sauce, with salmon

$20

Black Bean Burger

Hard roll, vegetarian black bean patty, field greens, roasted red pepper, pepper jack, sriracha aioli

🌶️🌱V
$18.75

BBQ Bacon Burger

Hard roll, (2) 1/4 lb. smash burger patties, field greens, tomato, bacon, cheddar, BBQ sauce

$22.75

Teriyaki Stir Fry (Polenta or Portobello)

Broccoli, carrots, roasted red pepper, red onion, zucchini, red cabbage, teriyaki sauce, white rice

🥛DF🌿VE🌱V
$22.50

Teriyaki Stir Fry (Salmon)

Broccoli, carrots, roasted red pepper, red onion, zucchini, red cabbage, teriyaki sauce, white rice, salmon

🥛DF
$26.75

Bourbon Bowl (Steak)

Vegetable fried rice, broccoli, roasted carrots, bourbon sauce with steak

🥛DF
$28.50

59 Parmesan - Eggplant

Penne pasta, red sauce, provolone cheese, Romano with fried eggplant

🌱V
$22.50

Potato Wedges

Side of potato wedges

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🌱V
$8.50

Broccoli

Side of broccoli

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🌱V
$7.25

Coleslaw

Side of coleslaw

🌾GF🌱V
$5

House Salad

Field greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, celery, carrot, crouton, balsamic vinaigrette

🌿VE🌱V
$8.50

Signature Soup (bowl)

House signature soup, bowl size

$11.50

Field Greens, Red Onion Hummus & Focaccia

Field greens, red onion, hummus, grilled focaccia

🌿VE🌱V
$15.20

Turkey Burgundy

Toasted whole wheat, roasted turkey, field greens, red onion, gorgonzola, red wine mayo

$18

Chicken Finger Wrap (Chicken/Polenta/Falafel)

Chopped romaine, tomato, bleu cheese dressing, with chicken, polenta, or falafel

$17.75

Spicy Tuna Wrap

Tuna salad, field greens, tomato, banana pepper, pepper jack cheese, sriracha aioli

🌶️
$17.50

Café Fish Fry

Fried beer battered haddock fillet, potato wedges, coleslaw, caper mayo, lemon

$21.50

Bourbon Bowl (Chicken)

Vegetable fried rice, broccoli, roasted carrots, bourbon sauce with chicken

🥛DF
$24

Cajun Alfredo (Salmon)

Penne pasta, broccoli, red onion, roasted red pepper, Cajun alfredo sauce with salmon

🌶️
$29.75

Hummus

Side of hummus

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🌱V
$8.25

Tabbouleh (side)

Side of tabbouleh

🌿VE🌱V
$6

Vegetarian Polenta 'Wings' (double)

20 polenta wings, bleu cheese, celery

🌱V
$27

Grilled Focaccia, Cucumber

Grilled focaccia with cucumber

🌿VE🌱V

Chicken Finger Classic (double)

8 chicken fingers, potato wedges, bleu cheese, celery

$35

Chopped Asian Salad (entrée)

Napa cabbage, cucumber, celery, carrot, edamame, pickled onions, crispy noodles, honey sesame

🥛DF🌿VE🌱V
$14

Harvest Salad

Field greens, roasted turkey, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, gorgonzola, red onion, balsamic vinaigrette

$19

Chicken Finger Salad

Chopped romaine, chicken finger strips, celery, carrot, bleu cheese dressing

$19.50

Café BLT

Hard roll, bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, mayo

$13

Café Reuben

Toasted rye, turkey or corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing

$18.75

Harvest Wrap

Roasted turkey, field greens, candied walnuts, dried cranberries, gorgonzola, balsamic vinaigrette

$18

Bourbon Wrap (Chicken/Polenta/Falafel)

Vegetable fried rice, bourbon sauce, with chicken, polenta, or falafel

$17.75

Fried Falafel Wrap

Fried falafel, field greens, tomato, red onion, feta, lemon-dill dressing

🌿VE🌶️🌱V
$17.75

Turkey Burger

Hard roll, ground turkey patty, field greens, tomato, red onion, honey mustard

$18.75

Burgundy Burger

Hard roll, (2) 1/4 lb. smash burger patties, field greens, red onion, gorgonzola, red wine mayo

$21.25

Teriyaki Stir Fry (base)

Pan-fried broccoli, carrots, roasted red pepper, red onion, zucchini, red cabbage, teriyaki sauce, white rice

🥛DF🌿VE🌱V
$19

Bourbon Bowl (base)

Vegetable fried rice, broccoli, roasted carrots, bourbon sauce

🥛DF🌿VE🌱V
$19

Cajun Alfredo (Chicken)

Penne pasta, broccoli, red onion, roasted red pepper, Cajun alfredo sauce with chicken

🌶️
$27.25

Basil Pesto Chicken Linguine

Linguine pasta, grilled chicken, basil pesto, cherry tomato, red onion, goat cheese

$24.50

Garlic Toast

Side of garlic toast

🌱V
$3.85

Vegetarian Polenta 'Wings' (single)

10 polenta wings, bleu cheese, celery

🌱V
$14.50

Signature Soup (cup)

House signature soup, cup size

$7.75

Signature Soup (quart)

House signature soup, quart size

$15.25

Field Greens, Lemon Sweet & Sour Beets

Field greens with lemon sweet & sour beets

🌿VE🌱V
$10.25

Smoked Mozzarella Bites

Red sauce, Romano

🌱V
$17

Chicken Finger Classic (single)

4 chicken fingers, potato wedges, bleu cheese, celery

$19.75

Salad, Soup & Bread

House, Caesar, or Chopped Asian salad with cup of soup and grilled focaccia

$19.75

Café Tuna Melt

Toasted rye, tuna salad, tomato, cheddar cheese

$17.75

Chicken, Bacon & Fig Sandwich

Hard roll, grilled chicken, field greens, tomato, bacon, fig jam, caramelized onion, goat cheese

$19

Chicken Finger Sub

Sub roll, chicken fingers or fried polenta, field greens, tomato, red onion, bleu cheese dressing

$19

Caesar Wrap (Salmon)

Chopped romaine, red onion, Caesar dressing, with salmon

$20

Chopped Asian Wrap (Salmon)

Chopped romaine, red cabbage, cucumber, edamame, crispy noodles, honey sesame dressing, salmon

$20

Lemon-Dill Salmon Wrap

Roasted salmon, romaine, roasted red peppers, cucumber, red onion, goat cheese, lemon-dill dressing

$21

Café Burger

Hard roll, (2) 1/4 lb. smash burger patties, field greens, tomato, red onion

$19.75

Bourbon Bowl (Polenta or Falafel)

Vegetable fried rice, broccoli, roasted carrots, bourbon sauce with polenta or falafel

🥛DF🌱V
$22.50

Bourbon Bowl (Shrimp or Salmon)

Vegetable fried rice, broccoli, roasted carrots, bourbon sauce with shrimp or salmon

🥛DF
$26.75

59 Parmesan - Chicken

Penne pasta, red sauce, provolone cheese, Romano with chicken

$24.50

Pickled Beets

Side of pickled beets

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🌱V
$6

Grilled Focaccia

Side of grilled focaccia

🌿VE🌱V
$4.50

Cajun Alfredo (Steak)

Penne pasta, broccoli, red onion, roasted red pepper, Cajun alfredo sauce with steak

🌶️
$31.50

Meatballs

Red sauce, Romano, grilled focaccia; priced each

$4.50

Fried Pickles

Cajun seasoning, Cajun ranch

🌶️🌱V
$14.50

Caesar Salad (entrée)

Romaine, crouton, red onion, Caesar dressing

🌱V
$14.75

59 Grilled Cheese

Texas toast, American cheese

🌱V
$9.95

Corned Beef on Rye

Toasted rye, roasted corned beef, coleslaw, Swiss cheese

$18

Grilled Chicken & Pesto Sandwich

Toasted garlic roll, grilled chicken, field greens, tomato, provolone, basil pesto

$18.75

Caesar Wrap (Chicken/Polenta/Portobello)

Chopped romaine, red onion, Caesar dressing, with chicken, polenta, or portobello

🌱V
$17.75

Chopped Asian Wrap (Chicken/Polenta/Portobello)

Chopped romaine, red cabbage, cucumber, edamame, crispy noodles, honey sesame dressing

🌱V
$17.75

Salmon Entrée

Broiled salmon fillet, cherry tomatoes, capers, basil white rice, broccoli, lemon

🥛DF🌾GF
$24.75

Cajun Alfredo (base)

Penne pasta, smoked sausage, broccoli, red onion, roasted red pepper, Cajun alfredo sauce

🌶️
$22.50

59 Parmesan - Meatball

Penne pasta, red sauce, provolone cheese, Romano with meatball

$23.25

Teriyaki Stir Fry (Steak)

Broccoli, carrots, roasted red pepper, red onion, zucchini, red cabbage, teriyaki sauce, white rice, steak

🥛DF
$28.50

Caesar Salad

Romaine, crouton, red onion, Caesar dressing

🌱V
$9.25

Chopped Asian Salad

Napa cabbage, cucumber, celery, carrot, edamame, pickled onions, crispy noodles, honey sesame dressing

🥛DF🌿VE🌱V
$9

House Salad (starter)

Starter house salad

🌿VE🌱V
$8.50

Chopped Asian Salad (starter)

Starter chopped Asian salad

🌿VE🌱V
$9

Tabbouleh (starter)

Starter tabbouleh

🌿VE🌱V
$10.25

Grilled Focaccia, Cucumber (starter)

Grilled focaccia with cucumber

🌿VE🌱V

Chicken Finger Classic (single 4)

Potato wedges, bleu cheese, celery

$19.75

Chicken Finger Classic (double 8)

Potato wedges, bleu cheese, celery

$35

Salad, Soup & Bread Combo

House, Caesar, or Chopped Asian salad with cup of soup & grilled focaccia

$19.75

Vegetarian Polenta 'Wings' (single 10)

Polenta wings, bleu cheese, celery

🌱V
$14.50

Vegetarian Polenta 'Wings' (double 20)

Polenta wings, bleu cheese, celery

🌱V
$27

Moroccan Falafel Salad

Field greens, falafel, tabbouleh, roasted carrots, artichokes, tomato, red onion, yogurt, Greek dressing

🌱V
$19

Chopped Asian Wrap - Chicken/Polenta/Portobello

Romaine, red cabbage, cucumber, edamame, pickled onion, crispy noodles, honey sesame dressing

$17.75

Grilled Portobello Sandwich

Hard roll, grilled portobello mushroom, field greens, tomato, hummus, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers

🌿VE🌱V
$17.75

Teriyaki Stir Fry (base vegetable)

Pan-fried vegetables, teriyaki sauce, white rice

🥛DF🌿VE🌱V
$19

Caesar Wrap - Chicken/Polenta/Portobello

Chopped romaine, red onion, Caesar dressing with chicken, polenta, or portobello

$17.75

Caesar Wrap - Salmon

Chopped romaine, red onion, Caesar dressing with salmon

$20

Bourbon Wrap - Chicken/Polenta/Falafel

Vegetable fried rice, bourbon sauce with chicken, polenta, or falafel

$17.75

Bourbon Wrap - Salmon

Vegetable fried rice, bourbon sauce with salmon

$20

Chicken Finger Wrap - Chicken/Polenta/Falafel

Chopped romaine, tomato, bleu cheese dressing with chicken, polenta, or falafel

$17.75

Chopped Asian Wrap - Salmon

Romaine, red cabbage, cucumber, edamame, pickled onion, crispy noodles, honey sesame dressing with salmon

$20

Fried Polenta or Falafel

🌱V
$18.50

59 Parmesan Bomber Chicken or Meatball

$19.50

Bourbon Wrap Chicken, Polenta, or Falafel

$17.75

Chopped Asian Wrap Chicken, Polenta, or Portobello

$17.75

Cajun Alfredo

🌶️
$22.50

Vegetarian Polenta 'Wings' double(20)

🌱V
$27

Chicken Finger Classic double(8)

$35

Caesar Wrap Chicken, Polenta, or Portobello

$17.75

Chicken Finger Wrap Chicken, Polenta or Falafel

$17.75

59 Parmesan Bomber - Fried Eggplant

Sub roll, red sauce, provolone cheese, Romano with fried eggplant

🌱V
$18.50

Teriyaki Stir Fry (Chicken)

Broccoli, carrots, roasted red pepper, red onion, zucchini, red cabbage, teriyaki sauce, white rice, chicken

🥛DF
$24

Salmon Entree

Broiled salmon fillet, cherry tomatoes, capers, basil white rice, broccoli, lemon

🥛DF🌾GF
$24.75

Cajun Alfredo Penne

$22.50

📸

No photos yet — be the first to share!