Is this your restaurant? Claim your free listing on RankIt.

Claim this listing →

Colter Bay

561 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA

Colter Bay is a burger joint in Fort Erie. Ranked #6 for Burgers in Fort Erie, with menu prices $5 – $23. See the full Burgers and Vegan rankings in Fort Erie.

Menu

Fish And Chips

Beer battered cod, fries, house-made slaw, tartar sauce

$19

Colter Bay Wedge

Panko-crusted spicy buffalo chicken, blue cheese, vegetables

🌶️
$17

Firehole Falls Nachos

Cheese, pico de gallo, pickled red onion, cilantro, jalapeño

🌶️
$14

Grilled Salmon Chopped

Grilled salmon, Brussels sprouts, cucumber, bacon, avocado, fried egg

$20

Old West Steak Salad

Grilled sirloin, avocado, cherry tomato, pickled red onion, greens

$19

Poutine

House-cut fries, melted cheddar curds, beef gravy

$12

Grilled Turkey

Grilled turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo

$17

Vegan Beyond Burger

Vegan Beyond patty, Daiya cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion

$17

Double Cheeseburger

Two 1/4 lb patties, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, American cheese

$17

Potato Skins

Thick slice bacon, sharp cheddar, herb sour cream, scallion

🥛DF
$12

Beef On Weck

Classic roast beef on weck roll with au jus, horseradish

$16

561 Short Rib Melt

Braised short rib, arugula, roasted garlic aioli, white cheddar

$18

Rock Steady Patty Melt

Two 1/4 lb patties, caramelized onions, swiss, special sauce

$17

French Connection

Roast beef, melted provolone, fries, French onion soup

$23

Soft Pretzels

Locally made Breadhive pretzels with sharp cheddar fondue

$5

Spicy Chicken Sandwich

Spicy brined chicken, pickle, pepper coleslaw, sriracha mayo

🌶️
$16

Chicken Caesar

Greens, parmesan, blackened chicken, croutons, Caesar dressing

$17

French Onion Soup

Slow-cooked beef & onion stock, croutons, provolone cheese

$9

Chicken Wings

Hot, Medium, Mild or BBQ with carrots, celery, blue cheese

🌶️
$18

Mac N Cheese

Sharp cheddar, smoked pork belly, caramelized onion, breadcrumbs

$15

Photos

📸

No photos yet — be the first to share!

Been to Colter Bay?

Rank its dishes and see how your picks compare with locals — free in the app.

Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there