🏪 Is this your restaurant? Claim your free listing on RankIt.

Claim this listing →

Penny's Coffee Shop

916 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA ↗

$5 – $45(716) 370-0308www.pennys.coffee ↗

Penny's Coffee Shop is a welcoming spot in Fort Erie where locals can enjoy a comforting meal and a fresh cup of coffee. Whether you're stopping in for breakfast or lunch, it's a friendly neighborhood destination in Fort Erie that keeps things simple and satisfying.

Menu

Chocolate Croissant

🥜NF🌱V
$5.50

Muffins

🥜NF🌱V
$3.85

Butter Croissant

🥜NF🌱V
$4.12

Baklava Latte

Honey latte with pistachio syrup

🌾GF🌱V
$6.05

Southern Tier

IPA Beer

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$6

Lox Sandwich

🥜NF
$14

Cold Brew

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.65

Latte

🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.40

Teliani Valley Saperavi

Dry Red Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$11

Cream Cheese Bagel Sandwich

🥜NF🌱V
$5.50

Chicken Shawarma Wrap

🥜NF
$12.50

BLT Sandwich

🥜NF
$9.90

Caesar Salad

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$12

Tiramisu

🥛DF🥜NF🌱V
$6.60

Flavor Syrups & Sauces

🥛DF
$0.75

Labatt Blue

IPA Beer

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$5

Very Berry Smoothie

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8.80

Mocha

🥛DF🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$5.50

Americano

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$3.85

Affogato

Espresso poured over vanilla ice cream

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$6.05

Hummus Toast

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8.50

Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich

🥜NF🌱V
$8.70

Hayburner

IPA Beer

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$6

Chicken Caesar Wrap

🥜NF
$14.50

Mukuzani

Red Dry Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8

Mimosa

Orange juice and prosecco

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$12

Chicken Pesto Panini

🥜NF
$16.45

Peanut Butter Toast

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🌱V
$9.50

Avocado Toast

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$9.50

Fratelli Cosmo Rose Prosecco

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$12

Turkish Coffee

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$3

Kindzmarauli Akhasheni

Red Semi-Sweet Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8

Teliani Valley Amber Blend

Dry White Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$12

Elicottville Blueberry

IPA Beer

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$6.50

Alexandrouli

Red Semi-Sweet Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8

42N Solshine

Lager Beer

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$7

Cookies

🥛DF🥜NF🌱V
$3.75

Espresso

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$3

Tea

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4

Espresso Martini

Espresso, vodka, coffee liqueur

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$14

Iced Americano

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$3.85

Smoked Salmon Toast

☪️H🥜NF
$12.95

Tuna Melt Panini

🥜NF
$13.15

Chai Latte

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.95

Sausage, Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich

🥜NF
$9.90

Hot Cocoa

🥛DF🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.40

Dila-O Rkatsiteli

Dry White Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$12

Aperitivo

Aperol Spritz, lemon, simple syrup

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$12

Strawberry Banana Smoothie

🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$7.70

Shawarma Chicken Flatbread

🥜NF
$16.50

Baia's Wine Krakhuna

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$35

Baklava

Flaky filo, pistachios, honey syrup

☪️H🌾GF🌱V
$3.60

Orange Mango Smoothie

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$7.70

Iced Tea

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.40

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

🌶️🥜NF
$15.45

Khvanchkara

Red Semi-Sweet Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8

1911 Black Cherry

Cider

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF
$8

Matcha Latte

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.40

Greek Salad

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$14

Cheese Melt Panini

🥜NF🌱V
$11

Cappuccino

🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$4.40

Begaso Saperavi

Organic Dry Red Wine

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$45

Odjaleshi

Red Semi-Sweet Wine - Glass

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$8

Drip Coffee

🥛DF🌿VE🌾GF🥜NF🌱V
$3.57

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

🌶️🥜NF
$11.80

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich

🥜NF
$9.90

Photos

📸

No photos yet — be the first to share!