Best Pizza in St. Catharines

20 places ranked · 1 community vote

Discover the best Pizza in St. Catharines, ranked with early community input and local data. Crust N Cream Pizza & Icecream currently holds the top spot, with Maestro's Pizzeria and Cat's Caboose among the other top picks. A standout dish to try: the Chicken Bacon Alfredo Pizza. Menu prices: $7 – $53. Add your own rankings to help others find great Pizza in St. Catharines.

Filter:

RankIt's starting order. Too few people have ranked here to set it yet.

How this order was made

A starting order RankIt set before anyone ranked these. It changes once people rank them head to head. How RankIt works

3

Cat's Caboose

Bean Bar Pita Pizza · Pizza Antipastos · Score Pizza

$6 – $38

Disagree with this order? Put it in yours.

Or keep your list in the app.

Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play

Think you know the best Pizza in St. Catharines?

  1. 1Crust N Cream Pizza & Icecream
  2. 2Maestro's Pizzeria
  3. 3Cat's Caboose

This is a starting order. Where would you put them? Drag the ones you have tried into your own order. Free in the app.

Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play

Free · No stars, no scores · Rankings are never for sale

Nearby Cities

Pizza in ThoroldPizza in PelhamPizza in Niagara FallsPizza in Niagara-on-the-LakePizza in Ridgeville