Taste something on this list?
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Regional Roundup · Orillia
Discover Orillia's top-rated restaurants. From shawarma to fine dining, here's where locals eat.
Orillia's restaurant scene doesn't announce itself. There's no food media frenzy, no celebrity chef pipeline, just a steady crop of spots where locals actually eat. And that's precisely why it works. From shawarma joints with lines out the door to a wine bar that treats its wine list like a living thing, this city has figured out something most places struggle with: doing one thing well, or doing several things without apology.
The food here punches above its weight because the restaurants aren't chasing trends. Express Shawarma stacks meat the way it should be stacked. Tent Kitchen + Wine Bar makes its pasta by hand and crisps its fried chicken without cutting corners. The Indian restaurants understand that spice should taste like spice, not just heat. This is a town that rewards places that show up and do the work.
Whether you're hunting a quick lunch, planning a date night, or feeding a group without fuss, Orillia has a restaurant that's already thought through what matters. Here's where to go.
The top-ranked restaurant in Orillia for good reason. This is shawarma done right, with meat that's properly spiced and stacked, served in fresh pita with all the right toppings. It's the kind of place locals queue for at lunch.
This is where Orillia gets serious about food. The pasta is house-made, the fried chicken and waffles are crispy-tender perfection, and the salads actually taste like someone cared. Casual enough for weeknight dinner but good enough to dress up for.
Real North Indian cooking in Orillia. The tandoori is properly charred, the paneer naan comes hot off the griddle, and classics like butter chicken taste like they belong in someone's kitchen, not a chain. The basmati rice is fluffy and perfectly seasoned.
Another solid Indian spot that gets the fundamentals right. Their paneer paratha is laminated and flaky, the biryani smells like it should, and you can taste the spices rather than just their heat. Great value for the quality.
Fresh sushi that doesn't feel like it traveled across the province to get here. The kana platter is generous and the fish quality shows. A reliable spot when you want rolls and nigiri that taste clean and bright.
Elevated Mexican cooking that goes beyond the standard fare. This place brings real technique and fresh ingredients to familiar dishes, making it feel less like a casual taco spot and more like someone's personal kitchen.
A wine bar that actually knows wine, with small plates that pair thoughtfully. The sandwiches are built with care, the desserts are worth lingering over, and the whole vibe says 'we're serious about this.' Perfect for a date night or catching up with friends.
If Express Shawarma has a line too long to wait, come here. The shawarma is seasoned well, the pita is soft, and the platters are filling without being heavy. A solid second choice in Orillia's shawarma conversation.
Asian cuisine that's thoughtfully prepared. The menu covers several cuisines but doesn't feel scattered. Clean flavors, proper technique, and the kind of restaurant that makes you feel like you've discovered something worth knowing about.
Casual Mexican food with soul. The cantina vibe is fun and the food tastes like it was made by people who actually enjoy cooking this cuisine. Great for groups and for when you want flavor without formality.
A neighbourhood spot that refuses to be boring. The menu changes and the kitchen clearly enjoys playing with flavors. Hit this place for lunch when you don't want the same thing you had yesterday.
More than just a gimmick, this place has food worth eating alongside the golf sims. It's the rare spot that's fun and feeds you well, making it perfect for casual group hangouts where everyone's happy.
Express Shawarma is the answer if you want speed, flavor, and zero pretense. Locals queue at lunch for a reason. The meat is properly spiced and stacked, the pita is fresh, and you're in and out without ceremony. If the line feels too long, Pita Land Shawarma delivers the same vibe without the wait. For something a step above casual but still relaxed, PICNIC cantina brings fun and flavor to group hangs, and The Clubhouse Bar & Golf Sim works as both a hangout and a place that actually feeds you well.
Tent Kitchen + Wine Bar is the natural choice. The house-made pasta, crispy-tender fried chicken, and thoughtful salads say someone cared about the menu. It's casual enough for weeknight dinner but polished enough to dress up for. Provenance Wine Bar and Commissary is your other strong move, especially if wine matters to the occasion. The small plates are paired with intention, the sandwiches are built with precision, and the whole room signals that this place takes itself seriously. It's the kind of spot where you linger and actually talk.
Yes. Family Taste Restaurant serves real North Indian cooking that tastes like it came from someone's kitchen, not a chain. The tandoori is properly charred, the paneer naan comes hot off the griddle, and the basmati rice is fluffy and seasoned right. 5 Rivers Restaurant & Bar - Indian Cuisine is a solid second option. Their paneer paratha is laminated and flaky, the biryani smells like it should, and you can taste the spices rather than just their heat. Either spot will deliver the fundamentals without compromise.
Get the RankIt app to rank your favourite dishes and see how your picks stack up against the locals.
Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there
Community-ranked restaurants across Ontario.