9 places ranked
Finding the best Pizza (Overall) in Niagara On The Lake is no easy feat, but the community has spoken and their picks are in. Right now, Il Gelato di Carlotta holds the top spot, with Budapest Bakeshop and The Old Winery Restaurant & Wine Bar rounding out the rankings as strong contenders. Across these spots, prices range from $2 to $62, giving options for a casual slice or a more elevated dining experience. If you have your own favourites in the area, adding your rankings helps the whole community discover what Niagara On The Lake has to offer.
Aggregated from all community votes.
The Old Winery Restaurant & Wine Bar
Cabernet · Cabernet Pizza · Chardonnay +11 more pizzas
Corks Wine Bar & Eatery
Pizza
Gyros on the Lake
Dinner Platter · Family Meal
Butler's Bar and Grill
Arrabiatta Sausage · Arrabiatta Sausage Pizza · BBQ Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese +13 more pizzas
Budapest Bakeshop
Pizza
Il Gelato di Carlotta
Pizza Margherita Panino
Bandana's Bar & Grill
Chicken Parm Sub · French Bread Pizza · Homemade Pizza Logs
Ontario House, aka Stone Jug
Pizza Logs · Pizza Monday
Domino's Pizza
Large Feast Pizza · Stuffed Cheesy Bread