St. Catharines / Pie Guys Pizzeria / The New Yorker

The New Yorker

XL pizza with homemade sauce, 3 cheese blend plus asiago and parmesan, topped with loads of pepperoni.

Pepperoni Pizza

$33.99

Sign in to mark as tried Want to try

See full menu at Pie Guys Pizzeria→

Rankings in St. Catharines

Best Pizza in St. Catharines

Dish category ranking

Often ranked above inPizza

Higher-ranked pizza in St. Catharines

Pepperoni Pizza

Crust N Cream Pizza & Icecream

Chicken Club Pizza

Maestro's Pizzeria

8 Slice 3 Item Pizza + 1lb of Wings

Cat's Caboose

1 Large Feast Pizza

Domino's Pizza

TopPizza in St. Catharines

Pepperoni Pizza

Crust N Cream Pizza & Icecream

Chicken Club Pizza

Maestro's Pizzeria

8 Slice 3 Item Pizza + 1lb of Wings

Cat's Caboose

Smokey BBQ Chicken Pizza

Rickijo's

Single Medium Pizza (Delivery)

Super 2 For 1 Pizza

Photos & Videos

Sign in to add photos

No photos yet. Be the first to share!

View Pie Guys Pizzeria Menu

Had the The New Yorker?

Add your ranking and help decide the best in St. Catharines. Free in the app.

Download on theApp Store Get it onGoogle Play

Free · No paid placements · Made for people who actually ate there